| Chronology |
Title |
Comment |
Local links, documents |
links to Source |
| April 6, 2003 |
THE KT TRANSITION AT YAXCOPOIL-1 DRILLHOLE. |
Keller launches abstract at the EGS/EUG/AGU assembly in Nice,
at the Chicxulub drilling Union session |
click here for pdf |
click here
for abstract in the abstract volume |
| September 26, 2003 (A) |
"WHAT KILLED THE DINOSAURS? GERTA KELLER REKINDLES K/T CONTROVERSY" |
Keller launches a press release from Princeton, which is picked
up by Cambridge Conference Network (CCnet)
of Benny Peiser: |
(short) and (here)
long local version |
click here for CCNet
online version |
| Oktober 3, 2003 |
CHICXULUB IMPACT PREDATES THE K-T BOUNDARY MASS EXTINCTION |
Keller et al paper 2004 in the Proceedings of the National
Academy of Sciences |
click here for local pdf |
Click here
for PNAS online version |
| Oktober 9, 2003 (B) |
"CHICXULUB IMPACT CRATER AND THE K/T MASS EXTINCTION,
REVISITED" |
Smit replies on Keller (A): |
click here for local
version |
click here for CCNet
online version |
| November 2, 2003 (C) |
CHICXULUB - THE NON-SMOKING GUN |
Keller replies on Smit (B), |
click
here for local version |
click here for CCNet
onlineversion |
| November 1, 2003 |
CHICXULUB - THE NON-SMOKING GUN |
The discussion is transferred to the Forum of the Geological
Society. Same title, but different paper. |
click
here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| November 12, 2003 |
AND YET.....IT SMOKES !! |
Smit replies to Keller's opening statements on the Geolsoc
Chicxulub forum |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| November 18, 2003 |
DID THE CRETACEOUS WORLD END WITH A SINGLE BANG, OR MANY SMALLER
ONES? |
Keller replies on the reply by J. Smit |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| November 25, 2003 |
STILL SMOKING ! |
Smit replies a second time |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| December 8, 2003 |
OLD EVIDENCE, PARTIAL INTERPRETATION |
Keller replies again (round three!) in Four Chapters! |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| December 8, 2003 |
(A) MULTIPLE SPHERULE LAYERS |
Chapter (A), lots of myths |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| December 8, 2004 |
(B) SILICICLASTIC ROCKS AND THE MYTH OF IMPACT-TSUNAMIS |
Chapter (B) irreproducible multiplication of burrows and disconformities |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| December 8, 2004 |
(C). CHICXULUB - YAXCOPOIL-1 |
Chapter (C), the Full Monte of the Yaxcopoil-1 core, total
confusion of dolomite crystals and forams |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| December 8, 2004 |
(D) CONCLUSIONS |
Chapter (D) twenty-five arguments - all easily countered |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| January 5, 2004 |
NOT A SHRED OF EVIDENCE HOLDS UP THAT CHICXULUB IS OLDER THAN
THE K/T BOUNDARY |
Smit replies to the foursome by Keller |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| January 10 |
SMITTEN WITH FAILED IMPACT-TSUNAMI THEORY |
Keller's last reply (as with all comments and reply, she
gets that last): It is all about courtroom tactics, not science |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| January 25 |
THE CHICXULUB DEBATE - WHAT NEXT? |
closing statement by Keller |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
| January 25
back to
top |
THE DEBATE HAS ENDED…FOR NOW! |
closing statement by Smit |
click here for local version |
GeoSoc debates (to reappear soon here) |
Keller,
Stinnesbeck